True cost accounting of food

True cost accounting (TCA) of food is a comprehensive and innovative methodology designed to go beyond the conventional price tag.

TCA research considers factors such as environmental degradation, public health implications, and social equity, offering a holistic perspective that enables policymakers and consumers to make more informed, sustainable decisions. This approach serves as a powerful tool in shaping practical policy solutions for a food system that values long-term sustainability over short-term economic gains.

Swette Center researcher taking a soil sample for TCA research.

TCA research at the Swette Center

The Swette Center is a trailblazer in TCA methodology.

Are the price premiums paid by consumers for plant-based meat alternatives worth the potential environmental and nutritional benefits?

Our researchers sought to answer this question by analyzing two popular plant-based meat alternatives, Beyond Burger® and Impossible Burger®, and comparing them with beef. After examining global warming potential, water consumption, dietary risks, and market retail prices, our team concluded that the benefits of choosing plant-based alternatives outweigh the higher cost consumers pay for them.

These peer-reviewed findings suggest that plant-based meat alternatives have meaningful environmental and health advantages over beef, and that policies supporting their affordability and accessibility may be worth considering.

Read the journal article

Alternatives to dairy milk have seen substantial growth in recent decades. Many consumers choose these beverages believing they are better for the environment or their personal health, however, the scientific evidence to support these assumptions is limited.

Our researchers addressed this gap by using a TCA approach to compare dairy milk with five popular plant-based alternatives: soy, almond, oat, coconut, and pea. The team examined whether the perceived benefits of plant-based milk alternatives hold true when global warming potential, dietary risks, and forced labor are taken into account.

Their findings indicate that plant-based alternatives can offer environmental, nutritional, and social benefits compared with dairy milk, but those benefits vary significantly by product and may not always justify the higher price paid by consumers. The study highlights that the choice among dairy milk and plant-based alternatives is more complex and nuanced that it may seem at first sight when externalities are considered.

Read the journal article

Read about it in the ASU news

Edible oils are widely used across the food industry, but they can have a vast range of impacts on human health, environmental sustainability, and social well-being. Some oils are more nutritious than others. Some require more water or energy to produce. And some are tied to broader concerns, such as deforestation and forced labor.

To better understand these trade-offs, our researchers examined the production and consumption of three globally important edible plant oils: palm, rapeseed, and coconut. By using existing life cycle assessment data within a TCA framework, the team quantified and, where possible, monetized the environmental and nutritional impacts associated with each oil.

Their research found that, when monetized, the health benefits of the oils were generally substantially greater than the environmental costs. The findings underscore the complexity of evaluating sustainability and raise an important question: how should environmental impacts and nutritional benefits be weighed when assessing the true costs and benefits of a food product? The study also provides a roadmap for integrating existing data and methods into TCA while highlighting important assumptions and limitations.

Read the journal article

Beef livestock ranching is an important agricultural occupation rooted in the history of the American West. However, recent media attention has brought attention to the environmental implications of livestock and health concerns around red meat. As these generalizations influence consumer perceptions around beef consumption, our team saw a need to employ a more robust understanding of beef livestock production as a complex socio-ecological system. 

Researchers at the Swette Center collaborated with Colorado State University on this pilot study to assess ranching in Arizona and Colorado using a TCA approach. The team analyzed publicly available data to understand how factors such as ranchers’ experience, labor, community networks, rangeland resources, and infrastructure contribute to the market value of cattle production.

This pioneering study contributes to a more complete understanding of the costs and benefits of cow-calf operations, and in doing so, helps inform holistic policy interventions.

Read the journal article

Read the Swette Center’s report

Our research in the news

“We’re not trying to tell people what to choose in the grocery store. We’re not trying to rank these from best to worst. It’s really giving people — and particularly policymakers — data that they can act upon. That’s the goal of true cost accounting,” said Kathleen Merrigan, executive director of the Swette Center for Sustainable Food Systems.

  • Uplifting Arizona food systems

    Uplifting Arizona food systems

    We’re driving food systems change across Arizona through place-based research, farmer support and community-building.

    Read more

  • Empowering Indigenous foodways

    Empowering Indigenous foodways

    We’re centering Indigenous knowledge and leadership to empower traditional foodways and support food sovereignty.

    Read more

  • Engaging the private sector

    Engaging the private sector

    We’re fueling food systems innovation by bridging research and business to scale profitable, sustainable solutions.

    Read more